Home assistant zigbee2mqtt vs zha It works quite well for me, except when it comes to exposing the battery level of certain devices like the IKEA sensors that use CR2032 batteries. Switching from one gateway solution to another can be a bit of a pain, depending on the number of Schnall dich an, denn wir tauchen tief ein in die Welt von ZHA und Zigbee2Mqtt! Hier noch eine kurze Anmerkung: Ich empfehle niemanden der mit ZHA simon42 Community ZHA vs. io. NathanCu (Nathan Curtis) November 28, 2024, 1:23pm 21. g. Check my Zigbee is one of the most popular wireless communication protocols for smart home devices, thanks to its low power consumption, long range, and robust mesh networking The process to compare Zigbee2MQTT vs ZHA vs deCONZ. Suppose I have such a device, is there any chance that I could get it working with ZHA, by creating a ZHA quirk myself? Could I use Zigbee2MQTT code as inspiration for that? Has someone done that before? Everyone has their preferences. 1 / Supervisor 2024. ZHA vs Zigbee2MQTT upvotes My Zigbee devices are a bit of a mess. Also, Zigbee2mqtt apparently added support for new devices quickly while ZHA I believe ZHA and zigbee2mqtt don’t support that. Zigbee2mqtt should support all the features while ZHA is missing some features from these devices. This has been asked before, but a long time ago, however I want to revisit it with a new angle I understand that Z2M and ZHA can be run on the same machine, so long as you have 2 coordinators and those coordinators only do one or the other My extension of the question is, a) can the coordinators be the same device (e. i. francisp (Francis) October 23, 2020, 2:34pm 103. Why cant Home Assistant do the same integration with zigbee2mqtt as they did with zwavejs2mqtt ditching the need for mqtt? And discontinue ZHA? Focusing on zigbee2mqtt with joint venture? I tried ZHA first, deCONZ seconds and Zigbee2MQTT last. I’ve seen mixed reviews on the Sonoff WiFi bridges, but have no first hand Hi all I’m a complete noob, in fact I’ve not even started anything yet. After 18 wipes and rebuilds going to try something else, ZHA. Hi, Looking at the well known Database of Zigbee devices, I noticed that there are quite some devices that are supported by Zigbee2MQTT, but not by ZHA. My take on it is here: ZHA Vs Zigbee2Mqtt - #3 by jerrm. I have successfully setup an SMLight coordinator using poe ethernet. Database of Zigbee devices compatible with ZHA, Tasmota, Zigbee2MQTT, deCONZ, ZiGate and ioBroker. I I’ve been starting with ZHA and I have realised that Zigbee2mqtt seems to have better device support for the current devices I’ve been buying like Aqara TVOC sensor and Aqara power plug. Nordic ZHA in Home Assistant does the job for most people, while Zigbee2MQTT is the king of supported devices. henry8866: I’m sorry for the poor experience you had, but saying integrations are the weak part of Home Assistant is just not true, sound like you don’t understand what integrations are, because otherwise you would not say that z2m is Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. I've tried ZHA, Zigbee2MQTT and deCONZ and personally would recommend deCONZ. → what device / chipset are your running ?? I’m actually looking for advices from some Zigbee2MQTT expert ! This article shows how to configure Z2M and ZHA to work with a single LAN zigbee adaptor: The author first configure the zigbee network under Home Assistant Community ZHA vs Zigbee2MQTT - Pros 'n Cons for conversion. All three work well when setup. I think the scenaria is pretty clear ;-) When i use Home Assistant to turn on the light, everything works. Reply reply Today I tried out ZHA (been using deCONZ) to see if I could get my ecosmart remotes to pair (I haven’t been able to pair them with Home Assistant using a Conbee II and deCONZ). Z2M supports more devices than ZHA, but I’m sure you If you’re new to Zigbee and/or Home Assistant, my recommendation is to use ZHA, which is Home Assistant’s built-in implementation. But I’m using ZHA for my Zigbee netwoork but notice that using Zigbee2MQTT may provide additional functionality for some of my devices as well as open up the possibility to use devices not available through ZHA (yet). Basically, use the one that supports the devices you have. If a device doesn’t work with ZHA and that is critical to your network, try Zigbee2MQTT or vice versa. Any help Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. Home Assistant Community deCONZ vs ZHA vs zigbee2mqtt. I’m looking at buying a refurb dell mini pc 16g ram and 250gb ssd to start and want to start with zigbee but I’m not sure if it’s zigbee or zigbee2mqtt I’m best using. Sending a command to each light individually (especially with transition effect or changing brightness) doesn’t change all lights smoothly because of all the requests. 0 /OS 13. ZHA certainly seems more flexible in what it will be able to offer (and for example, my Hue Dimmers can support ZHA developer dmulcahey begun work on a side-project called “ZHA WS” (e. , 87%) even though After using ZHA and zigbee2mqtt I prefer zigbee2mqtt dashboard over ZHA configuration. Both have some OTA support, z2m is probably better, but the latest zha toolkit can now use the z2m OTA repository, leveling the playing field, even if not fully GUI integrated. “ZHA WebSocket”) which goal I understand was to break out the ZHA integration component into its own stand-alone websocket server application and re-implement ZHA in a fork that uses that socket interface instead, using a client-server model architecture: I’ve recently started on the whole HA journey. I had been running Zigbee2MQTT with this setupfor a couple of years now with about a dozen sensors from Aqara and IKEA Tradfri lightbulbs. Automations will be in Home Assistant. 08. It appears to be more reliable than the other options, but this is purely anecdotal. ADMIN MOD Conbee vs Sonoff and ZHA vs Zigbee2MQTT . Actually it's the same with zigbee2mqtt because MQTT plugin It seems to me ZHA is loosing the “battle” to zigbee2mqtt, device support is lacking and its not trivial to add new devices with quirks in ZHA. So which am I best going with zigbee ZHA vs zigbee2mqtt. Light turns on and timer is started. I’m thinking of moving it all to Conbee. two Sonoff USB dongles) b) are there any I am having random problems with this setup RaspBerry Pi 5 (8GB) ConBee III Home Assistant OS ( Core 2024. Someone is telling me Zigbee2MQTT is better. If time passed > 2min, fan is turned on. If you are using some more rare device it might also be a good In this article, I present what the differences are between Zigbee2MQTT, ZHA, and deCONZ. I ran the Zigbee2MQTT using a CC253x coordinator from almost the birth of Zigbee2MQTT as well with good success. . I’m going It supports more devices, gives you more control, let's you put your coordinator wherever you want (not just where HA is), and gives you more independence from HA, if you ever need it. Hi everyone, I recently moved (well, still moving!) from Samsung SmartThings (ST) to Home Assistant using the HA Green as my platform with a SkyConnect dongle. 1 Like. This thread is archived Running Home Assistant official Docker image on a NUC with Ubuntu 18. ZHA is not bad, but Z2M is a godsend. So the Conbee stick works with both ZHA and deCONZ, HUSBZB-1 is for ZHA but includes Z-Wave, and for zigbee2mqtt I need a CC2531 and debugger, is that correct? Strawpoll. Zigbee2MQTT - Meine Endgültige Empfehlung! Zigbee - Home Assistant Community kurz überflogen und zumindest der Beginn sieht für diese Richtung nicht positiv aus ZHA is a proprietary home assistant component, you cannot use it outside of the ecosystem. zigbee2mqtt uses MQTT which separates the Zigbee processing from Home Assistant. Available for free at home-assistant. In that thread, there are reports of better Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. What is best is what works fro you. After many years of me helping many ZHA and Zigbee2MQTT end-users here in this community forum or other support channels for those two projects I can tell you from my own first-hand experience that while it is true that most users do tend to use stable wired Ethernet LAN connection and therefore those often seem to have no problems there are ZHA vs Z2M. I’ve noticed many times in forum posts, and by looking at Hi started getting into Home Assistant over Christmas last year. ZHA has it's own devices section where you can list and analyze ZHA devices. Perhaps ZigBee2MQTT? Or any other suggestions. 1-1 Zigbee on channel 11 and wifi 2. All three have good development and get new devices added. I showed you in the last videos, how you can install your Zigbee devices using ZHA, Zigbee2MQTT or deCONZ. 4 on channel 6 My problem is that suddenly everything stops working. Most of the time, the battery level always shows 100% even after several months, or it gets stuck at a fixed percentage (e. I have used both and Hi so I’m preparing a blueprint for my smart home and I need some help understanding & deciding which hub & interface I should use. All three options support majority of devices. It has been a really good experience: quite stable with few problems, mixing devices from multiple manufa Database of Zigbee devices compatible with ZHA, Tasmota, Zigbee2MQTT, deCONZ, That is not the consensus. Perfect to run on a Raspberry Pi or a local server. Okee two questions, i am running HASS with a Conbee II stick and i use ZHA. I currently have about 48 zigbee router devices and 12 end devices that I want to I have been using both the TubesZB, ZBDongle-P implementation of the TI CC2652P chip set with Zigbee2MQTT using the ‘Coordinator revision 20211217’ with Zigbee network with 20 to 40 devices for 2 years with very good success. First Phoscon, then Zigbee2MQTT (Z2M) and most recently Zigbee Home Automation (ZHA): I have extensively tested all three ZigBee gateway software solutions with Home Assistant and am now using ZHA, which is also the primary topic of this article. Zigbee2mqtt has support for more devices, but ZHA has support for more adapters/coordinators. I’ve been digging around here as of late and seeing all kinds of great ZHA-based Blueprints popping up and can’t help myself but wonder if I’m putting too much work into Deconz when the future seems to be moving over to ZHA with my ConBee II stick. zigbee2mqtt, zha, zigbee. deCONZ also failed to control the entire set of device brands I own (IKEA, Innr, OSRAM/LEDVance, Philips/Signify). Im going to start with simple automations, but I will want the most advanced features in Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. 1 Zigbee2MQTT addon 1. Spent the best part of the 10 months trying to get a stable zigbee2MQTT up and running. The process was as follows: For every integration or add-on, I had to start with a fresh Home Assistant installation and then I installed the integration or add-on so Hello everyone, I currently have Zigbee2mqtt set up for all my Zigbee devices. I’m looking to go for something I don’t have to replace for a some time. And it doesn’t seem limited to Sonoff (which is not surprising, as the same chipset and identical firmware are common). Having come from a dev background, the learning curve is not too steep (although yaml) I end up getting a Sonoff zigbee 3 usb dongle to act as my zigbee coordinator, and it works really well. All my devices are connected via ZHA, as that seemed the way to go. From what I I recently started a new smart home setup after moving into a new apartment. Configuration. 1 / Frontend 20240906. I prefer ZigBee2mqtt because I'm not tied up to home assistant. 4. If you plug your Zigbee dongle in, Home If you are not using Home Assistant or if you need to run the smart home controller and the Zigbee control software separately, the choice is simple: use Zigbee2MQTT. This has great benefits in my setup since I use many GU10’s grouped up as pairs. ZHA was in an early state, can communicate directly with the coordinator hardware (or - to my knowledge - via deCONZ REST API, too), but failed to pair some Innr bulbs. What coordinator/zigbee stick are you using? Zigbee2mqtt has monthly Converting between ZHA (built-in Zigbee Home Assistant) and Zigbee2MQTT is a lot more involved, and neither solution is going to 100% solve every issue. Current Gateways: Hue, Conbee II, The official “Zigbee Home Automation” (ZHA) integration is the Zigbee gateway solution that is natively built into Home Assistant and is what is official supported by the Home Assistant founders + Nabu Casa (and really the Zigbee gateway solution that this specific forum is about other than Zigbee devices/hardware products that can possibly be used with this official As discussed here: Sonoff Zigbee USB Dongle not working with IKEA Tradfri buttons, lots of people are have trouble with Ikea shortcut buttons (in particular — but possibly other Ikea remotes as well). jerrm (Jerrm) November 27, 2023, 5:16am 3. Aqara’s deCONZ vs ZHA vs zigbee2mqtt. For example I can make my Tasmota or esphome devices listen to ZigBee sensors via mqtt and do automations without the home assistant involved. Snappy and reliable are the goals. 40. Would people recommend starting with ZHA or Zigbee2MQTT? I'm running HA in a Docker Container if that makes any difference. Zigbee. 0) MQTT Integration Mosquitto broker addon 6. Powered by a worldwide community of tinkerers and DIY enthusiasts. Sonoff WiFi Bridges. I With ZHA it’s generic and some things are not ideal. Sawtaytoes: I’m not sure how large these firmwares are, but I can only do a few a night for the 30 that needed updating. 04. What I’m worried about is the “HUB Software”. 9. It worked! BUT, I couldn’t get my Xiaomi PIR sensor to pair with ZHA. deConz seems to have issues with groups, ZHA is not really mature. (See TL;DR below to skip my self-pitying life story!) My first ever post was asking how I can get the “decoupled” setting exposed and working for Zigbee switches (Aqara Smart Wall Switch H1 for Hello, Who is running ZHA and Z2M on the same LAN coordinator ? I’d be very interested to read your feedback. This is a bit harder to set up but in the long run is more robust. However, here’s why you might want to do this: If I pair different devices in Zigbee2MQTT or ZHA while they are both connected to the same coordinator, the features each integration support for the device will show up as usual. njk wroeex tzjtqukk wkr xsu xlp toksvuz lzglh vwdycfue ulcna